The telephone is the life line of a virtual company. Since we rarely see each other face to face, we use the telephone and email as our primary methods of communication. We began using VOIP services from Vonage all the way back in 2004. In fact, I believe that I was one of Vonage’s first customers. Since that time, I have personally moved off of Vonage and use a service called BroadVoice. The primary reason is that Broadvoice has superior international calling than Vonage and it was also less expensive. Now days, VOIP is quite common and is offered usually by your internet provider. Virtually all PC Pitstop employees have some sort of VOIP for communications puroposes.
Given how long we have been customers of VOIP technology, we have unique view of the quality and benefits of the services.
The most important reason that we went with VOIP is due to price. Back in the old days, telephone carriers would charge by the minute for long distance calls. This became cost prohibitiveĀ as we didn’t want to be skimping on our telephone conversationsĀ because we knew the clock was ticking. Since then, almost all telephone plans have an unlimited option. In addition, VOIP comes with a slew of features such as call waiting, caller ID, and 3 way calling. All of these features are invaluable when running a business. Another very cool feature is that they record all of your incoming and out going calls into a password protected database. This has come in handy, when you are looking for a telephone number of someone, or you need a record of when a telephone call actually occurred. It has been a life saver more than once.
We at PC Pitstop are certainly heavy users of VOIP but this technology is far from perfect. Here are some of the common problems with VOIP.
1. Garbled audio. This happens in both directions. At times, it is difficult for others to understand what you are saying, and it is sometimes difficult to understand what the other person is saying. The main reason why this happens is because your internet connection has lost some of its capacity. It happens from time to time. It can also be because someone else is downloading something across the same router that is connected to your VOIP box. It also happens when you are uploading something. Often, I want to upload something to the other party and then discuss. Frequently, we will need to wait for the file to upload before we can resume our conversation.
They say that there are settings on your router to give priority to the VOIP box. I have tried several times, and this solution has never been too successful. In fact, it sometimes makes the problem worse.
This problem does not happen frequently. Let’s say once a month, but when it does happen, it can be frustrating.
2. Missed Calls. This happens to me about once a month or so. Just yesterday, I called one of our employees and left a message. The problem is that the phone never rang on the other end so they never had a chance to pick up. I get all my voicemails in my email (which is another handy feature), but sometimes the phone never rings and then I get a voicemail. This doesn’t happen a lot. Let’s say once every two months but it does happen.
3. One Way Calling. This one is the most frustrating, and when it happens it makes you want to go insane. Sometimes when I call someone, they can hear you but you can’t hear them. Or vice versa. Usually, we just hang up and call again. The problem is that the issue does not go away that quickly. Quite often, it will take 4-5 calls until you are having a conversation.
4. Dropped Calls. Sometimes you are just talking and then the entire call is lost. Often, in mid sentence, you suddenly hear a busy signal. This one is no big deal, because you just call back again and you are back in business although you have to remember where you left off.
Like I said before, we are still big fans of VOIP. In my case, it is particularly important since I live in Brazil and the calls would be international and more costly. I save literally save hundreds of not thousands of dollars a month. That said, VOIP is not without its flaws and certainly when compared to a plain old land line.
I live in Douglas Arizona and can’t get skype of voip phone service to work. Cox cable doesn’t have cable phone service here either.
I use Cox broad band internet.
Skype wont refund money for their junk!
Tom
The gripe I have with VOIP is that there is no faxing available; and sometimes the other party will not accept e-mail as a substitute.
Having used ITP Voip for almost 3 years, I have never experienced the difficulties you mention other than due to a power outage.
It’s a pity you don’t have anything better to do or contribute than “spell check?”
Opps, wrong thread! Meant for pete
I got my system plugged in to APC 750 battery backup. Kept my phone on the hour plus when power pole got hit.
Have had Vonage since 2005, never had any of the above problems. Used VOIP
at work for 4 years, again none of the above problems.
I think that a good QOS (quality of service) on the communications will prevent many VOIP call issues.
So, letting all signals ‘compete’ for the bandwidth is just asking for trouble and our tolerance for the above issues is much lower than waiting for a server to respond….?
COOL ARTICLE, SIS.
Puroposes – it’s a pity you don’t have spell checkers.
I’ve used Ooma for about 18months and it just keeps getting better, the quality of the calls is far superior to any telephone service I ever had.
I use Vonage and do not have a land line. I really like the call forwarding. I use it when traveling to have calls sent to my cell phone. I do have times where the phone doesn’t ring and it goes to voicemail. It never happened until this year and I have had it for over four years. Also, the higher mps the better the voice sounds.
I use Ooma and I love it, for $3 and change per month it is unbeatable.
If you have all those problems, and pay the rates I just saw posted on the Broadvoice website, you seriously need to switch to Joiphone. I’ve used them since SunRocket crashed and burned. Great rates and great service!
I too was an early user of Vonage back around 2004/2005. About a year ago I switched to Ooma. I have been more than happy. I now own my own dial tone. With Ooma you purchase the hardware for a one time charge ($100-$200) and there are no monthly fees other than federal taxes which, in my case, is only $3.47 / month. The call quality is crystal clear and the overall service blows Vonage off the map. Check it out at ooma.com
The author is bang on.
All the described problems are more or less common.
It’s probable that the problems are related directly to the level of sophistication of local broadband facilities. So for example in New York the problems described might be rare, but in say Raratonga they might be quite common.
BTW these are just for example, for all I know Raratonga may be better than NY.
I have Magic Jack and the only problem is if I’m too close to my wireless router it makes the incoming voice signal to cut in and out. but non of the problems you mention. Love mine. AT&T can Jam’it in their A……T&T
Thanks for this information Steve. I also have Magic Jack and now know why this happens. I’ll stay away from my router from now on.
I’ve had virtually none of the problems that rcheng speaks of either. And I’ve been a Vonage customer since they’ve been in business as well so I guess that makes me just as much of an experienced user. I don’t doubt that “your mileage (with VOIP) will vary” based on the quality of your INTERNET service, but over the years here in the NYC area I’ve had tremendous success with Road Runner, Optimum On-Line and for the last 3-4 years with Verizon FiOS as well.
I have never once had a dropped or one way call. I believe that I’ve had one missed call (it involved work claiming to have called for my wife, the phone never rang (nor was there anything on the caller ID) but when I checked the call log at Vonage.com it showed a call from them. One missed call in almost 10 years isn’t much to complain about. Back in the dark ages when I had POTS it wasn’t perfect either. I have a dedicated Vonage fax line as well and it also works like a charm (I use an HP LaserJet 1536dnf MFP). I have had another rare and insignificant problem that rcheng didn’t mention. On occasion a recently deleted voicemail will reappear when I check my messages. Other than strange it isn’t really a problem, it happens extremely infrequently, maybe a couple three times a year. Much better than not getting a voicemail which has thankfully never happened.
Lastly although I’m completely unfamiliar with BroadVoice I’d be shocked to find that they have a better deal than Vonage does for international calling. My wife and I both work for the airlines and travel internationally all month long. We can (and do) call 60 some odd countries for free. And in the last couple months a newly added feature allows you to add one cell phone with the same rate plan as you have on your regular phone line. So now I can use my cell phone to call all over the world for free too. (Vonage isn’t providing cell phone service, but you register your cell number with them then dial an access number, punch in a 4 digit pin then the international number and you get connected for free. Not as convenient as “Truphone Anywhere” (which I was using until Vonage added this feature, but free is even better than the 6 cents a minute that Truphone charges to use their service. Truphone is more convenient because it routes the call from your cell phone automatically when it detects that you dialed an international number. No access number to dial, no pin, it just does it all magically from behind the scenes.
But overall I really can’t agree with the assessment of Vonage by rcheng. They are as trouble free as phone calling can get.
Most problems seems to crop up when you are behind a firewall. I agree with others that QOS is important. If you run with no firewall all seems fine. The lack of ISP/ modem documentation and documentation in general certainly contributes to the problem.
As a VOIP user for about 5 years behind a firewall, I have experienced most of the problems mentioned in the article.
How about writing an article on where to find good setup documentation for all major ISP/ modems and VOIP service combos? Including setting up port-forwarding for all modems, not just a few generic firewall guides.
Thanks
I left ATT after 45 years of domination in the market. I have had Ooma for about 9 months and am somewhat satisfied, I have trouble with lags, pings, and echoes at different times, I have contacted Ooma’s tech line but to this date they have NOT been able to explain or fix the problem. The price is great.
when you have the voice-enabled cable modem there will be contention of bandwidth during periods when both voice and data are active.
One sure way to be free of this issue is to have voice and data on their own separate modems. Could you get them to register your subscription on separate modem’s Mac Addresses?
This will take care of a few issues š
I replaced my ATT line with a magicJack plus. I have a pair of 85 Mbps wall-Plugged Ethernet Adapters that are fast enought for the purpose. The adapters alow me to have my home phone base in my bedroom and the router in my office. I do get a little chop on the line on Fri. and Sat. nites, I think this happens when my Cox cable slows down.
I have been using mJ for over four years and I am happy with it. The only draw back I find is that the line goes dead after 90 minutes. A quick call back resumes the conversation.
I have saved over $1800 in the last four years, not to mention the long distance savings.